Eli

Hacksaw Ridge Sound format

62 posts in this topic

 

2 minutes ago, yorac said:

Mate, rewatched the scenes on the US disc, not a problem, one night scene a bit ordinary but np here......

cool, might have to borrow yours to watch before buying myself a copy :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, browny said:

 

cool, might have to borrow yours to watch before buying myself a copy :P

Am going to watch it in full again on the weekend mate, but happy to do a lenda.......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 hours ago, yorac said:
No issues with the PQ on the US disc from what I can see mate, got it a couple of weeks ago.........

 

35 minutes ago, yorac said:
Mate, rewatched the scenes on the US disc, not a problem, one night scene a bit ordinary but np here......

You obviously just don't have an eye for this sort of thing ;):). There is nothing wrong with that, it means the banding doesn't affect your enjoyment. The banding is there though (it's quite severe in places), it has been proven, and there is no disputing it. It has been discussed a bit in the U.S. Blu-ray and UHD threads on Blu-ray.com, however if you can't see it then perhaps you should mention your experience there:

http://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=286086

http://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=286083

Personally, I wouldn't though, If you value your credibility :)

Edit: Added a sentence.

 

Edited by Cevolution

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, muriwai said:

Is it the 4k disc or blu disc that has the banding issues?watched the 4k last night and didnt notice any banding?maybe I don't know wat to look for?

The 4k US disk is the good one for lack of banding Muri ; and the one with the atmos track :)

http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Hacksaw-Ridge-4K-Blu-ray/168526/#Review

In fact [ if you don't trust the distributors ] one could be forgiven that they;re trying to wean us off 2k bluray by giving more thought to the mastering of the uhd disc and screwing with the 2k version - only if you think its a conspiracy of course :angry: Of course the 2k version loosing the atmos object audio track with other titles is just a coincidence .. depending on your outlook ..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, Cevolution said:

 

You obviously just don't have an eye for this sort of thing ;):). There is nothing wrong with that, it means the banding doesn't affect your enjoyment. The banding is there though (it's quite severe in places), it has been proven, and there is no disputing it. It has been discussed a bit in the U.S. Blu-ray and UHD threads on Blu-ray.com, however if you can't see it then perhaps you should mention your experience there:

http://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=286086

http://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=286083

Personally, I wouldn't though, If you value your credibility :)

Edit: Added a sentence.

 

Never concerned with what others can see mate, just what I can see, the issues may well be there, I don't suffer from DLP rainbows either, doesn't mean they're not there.

Don't bother with OS forums as like here there is little tolerance for others views/tastes/opinions, the only things most forums have in common nowadays is a lack of respect for anyone who doesn't play the bandwagon game.

Apologies for going a little off topic folks..........

 

B):rolleyes::)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks cwt,yes I have the USA import,and watched the 4 k version ,as stated didnt notice any thing untoward on my "Lycra " screen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 20/03/2017 at 9:54 AM, :) said:

sorry pimple elephant all comes to mind. in any case just want to watch the film. not into conspiracies around distribution of it. am sure theres all sorts go on.

Not really a conspiracy ... Cevolution is spot on and we are likely to see more of this sort if tactic in the future.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 19/03/2017 at 11:55 AM, :) said:

i was about to grab it locally...doesnt this sh!t you ! 

 

might just wait till its on uhd... when ever that is ...

I have a UHD Copy with blu ray coming from Amazons due this week

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 19/03/2017 at 0:37 PM, ... said:

Bit of a trend with local releases lately.....<_<

Arrival -> 5.1 DTS HDMA

Doctor Strange -> only 5.1 DTS HDHR!!!  (is 7.1 DTS HDMA in the US & UK)

I also have Arrival UHD and Blu ray Coming out with other movies for US Amazins (Hacksaw)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gere we go Again. Australia People are Second Class. Most People Don't buy from the US at Amazons and Cant buy 4k and Atmos Movies in Australia yet they are 4K and Atmos in the USA for the same movie.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/19/2017 at 0:50 PM, Cevolution said:

Some is under statement. The U.S. 1080p Blu-ray should really be avoided due to the extreme amount of banding: 

http://forum.blu-ray.com/showpost.php?p=13342943&postcount=46568

...

 

In the image above that's more than just subtle banding from inadequate bit-depth. There are strong hints of quite different colours in the different bands. Something very odd has occurred.

In the opinion of one reviewer (at http://www.michaeldvd.com.au/Reviews/Reviews.asp?ID=11444 under the heading Transfer Quality):-

Quote

The banding issue is so bad on the Region A Blu-ray that the disc could be considered defective and should be recalled.

Edited by MLXXX

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, MLXXX said:

 

In the image above that's more than just subtle banding from inadequate bit-depth. There are strong hints of quite different colours in the different bands. Something very odd has occurred.

In the opinion of one reviewer (at http://www.michaeldvd.com.au/Reviews/Reviews.asp?ID=11444 under the heading Transfer Quality):-

The guy that wrote the review you linked me to, goes by the name of StrayButler91 on Blu-ray.com, he is the member I was discussing this issue with in one of the links I posted earlier in this thread.

Lionsgate have a habit of putting out 1080p discs with crappy masters and video encodes, that are riddled with banding, they have been doing it for years. They often go all out for the audio on their releases, but their video masters and encodes for 1080p Blu-ray's are amongst the worst in the industry. Those that put audio first, like some on this site, just often don't notice. The U.S. 1080p version of Hacksaw Ridge is probably the worse I've encountered from Lionsgate. As you stated, something strange has occurred, however it's not an isolated incident, some other titles from Lionsgate have had similar issues:

http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/screenshot.php?movieid=171583&position=14

Edit: Inserted a few words. Also corrected a spelling error.

Edited by Cevolution

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't now why anyone thinks anything has changed from the studios attitude towards Australia, it's not just Lionsgate.

This is the reason I continue to buy from Amazon US, if you pre order it's not that much dearer than new release here, and almost guaranteed better quality, if you're prepared to wait you can get some good bargains, I recently got Captain Fantastic and Don't Breather $32aud delivered.

And of course the issues mentioned are why people still illegally download and why I have no sympathy for the greedy studio bastards when it happens.....

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just as a heads up, curiosity got better of me. I ended up grabbing a local copy of hacksaw ridge. it a fantastic movie after all.

and boy is it a cracker in the PQ stakes ...

I have to also say I am 100% not a pixel peeper type, so from the outset I never set out to look for banding and such ... infact looking back on this thread I can say the banding identified in pics/scenes etc on the us release blu-ray are certainly not in my viewing present in the aussie release....

 

However....

 

I could not by any means NOT help notice the banding in the scene below on the aussie blu-ray release...

I kid you not if not seeing this gee am not sure what to say. this scene is the one where he is saying "just one more " just one more" I didnt get the time stamp but its towards the end of the movie last 20-30 min or so.

Its a pretty dark scene and with smoke and back lit...kind of thing probably not kind for banding/posteurisation. note i've used a dslr to best capture this ... it is pretty much as how it looks though exaggerated some what here with the camera shot close up... i.e. shot not taken from viewing position. and also note in movement this might be less obvious. its certainly something I noticed sitting back in the main viewing position so easily seen with movement.

this is one of the segments ...

32721036204_6004dfc1db_c.jpg

from another angle

33564502225_ddacc9da13_c.jpg

bit closer up,

33181383980_2861721034_c.jpg

32721153874_cd522d3b2b_c.jpg

closer again,

32720990874_61d1018a0b_c.jpg

this is from a segment of scene that follows,

33564630755_a2a6c53d22_c.jpg

 

however I must add re posteurisation/banding as far as the aussie release goes... this was it. I didnt notice anywhere else in the release...however its not something I seek out to see and I am not one of those that pixel peep either. and the blu-ray is a stunner PQ wise otherwise.

be interesting to see what the uhd is like PQ wise. 

the aussie release even though comes without atmos. I can tell you the neural X post processing of the DTS-HD MA track did bring out some great hight info. eg bullets whizzing around above and such.

 

obviously this is not 3D audio, but adds well to the experience and will be interesting to see how much better the atmos track wih the full 3D audio experience is for this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just thought I would mention MLXXX, the images that I posted on Blu-ray.com, which I posted links to in this thread, weren't screen captures, they were photos that I took with an iPhone, therefore the colours you see in the bands in these images aren't an accurate representation of what's on the disc. They were just meant to give people an idea of the differences between the two versions. The third link I posted was to actual screen caps, and are accurate to what's on the disc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isn't the banding due to the video being 8bit (256 steps) on BD and 10bit (1024) on UHD?  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, yorac said:

I don't now why anyone thinks anything has changed from the studios attitude towards Australia, it's not just Lionsgate.

This is the reason I continue to buy from Amazon US, if you pre order it's not that much dearer than new release here, and almost guaranteed better quality, if you're prepared to wait you can get some good bargains, I recently got Captain Fantastic and Don't Breather $32aud delivered.

And of course the issues mentioned are why people still illegally download and why I have no sympathy for the greedy studio bastards when it happens.....

 

 

Agree entirely ... but we did have a small golden period there where we were getting nearly as good as the US ... 4K seems to have brought all the old sloppy habits back out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
56 minutes ago, MarkTecher said:

Isn't the banding due to the video being 8bit (256 steps) on BD and 10bit (1024) on UHD?  

we shouldnt be seeing banding like this with blu-ray more case of mastering mis hap or sloppiness 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
55 minutes ago, :) said:

we shouldnt be seeing banding like this with blu-ray more case of mastering mis hap or sloppiness 

Pretty poor isn't it... we pay a premium price to obtain best PQ and they release sloppy [email protected]:hmm:

The lack of 7.1 on some AUS releases is just an annoyance. We should be able to just grab a copy from the store, without extensively researching each title and be assured that it is the whole package.

If they keep playing games like this with UHD BD's too, they'll end up alienating their own customer base.

2 hours ago, MarkTecher said:

Isn't the banding due to the video being 8bit (256 steps) on BD and 10bit (1024) on UHD?  

Not sure if that has happened in this case;

Much of this is likely the result of shooting exclusively on the Arri Alexa and Red Epic Dragon camera systems

JSmith :ninja:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now



  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.