Sign in to follow this  
jmone

X30 Vs 9000W

Recommended Posts

Ugg I get it now (another reason I like my light emmiting panel). So what is the cost of these 100" screens in Oz and is their a prefered retailer? Owen, I know you are a fan of the X30 but what would the combination of these sort of screen be like withthe Epson (for my current home situation the wireless HDMI is a big plus). The other option is I could add a HDMI Wireless Bridge to the X30..

Edited by jmone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding out of box performance of JVC and epson. I think the default setting like Cinema mode in JVC is fairly accurate and it require very little adjustment. With regard to Epson you can get 3.5 years of warranty on the product but not on the bulb you will need to read the fine print on their warranty and on their previous range Epson cover the lamp for a year or 750 hours whichever come the eraliest.

not correct on the warranty. I actually owned the previous flagship epson 5500 and current 9000. the warranty you are getting muddled in your head. Its something I not only confirmed with epson but also retailer and service centre not only for the previous model but also the current. and the fine print is actually quite clear, but I checked anyway.

http://www.epson.com...jector_3Y3Y.asp

the projector without lamp is warranted for 3 years. the lamp supplied with the projector is warranted for 3 years. if you buy a lamp separate to the projector it is warranted to 12 months or 750 hours which ever comes first.

re the x30 if I bought one, I would be getting it calibrated. re the x3 before out of box needed calibration to my eyes.. And many do calibrate and also run a external scaler to have the isf capability to fully calibrate it. :) its also the reason some bought the x7 and looking at the x70 for full ISF calibration the x30 doesnt have,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ugg I get it now (another reason I like my light emmiting panel). So what is the cost of these 100" screens in Oz and is their a prefered retailer? Owen, I know you are a fan of the X30 but what would the combination of these sort of screen be like withthe Epson (for my current home situation the wireless HDMI is a big plus). The other option is I could add a HDMI Wireless Bridge to the X30..

in my opinion, check out for your own eyes. while these ambient light rejecting screens do exist. like their benefits they also do have draw backs. Apart from being quite expensive vs conventional screens. check out for your self to decide :)

re wireless hdmi, dvdo provide the same tech as the epson as add on its a $399 item, not sure if available as yet in australia

http://store.spectracal.com/dvdo-air-wireless-hdmi-connection-system.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was ready to pull the trigger on one of these but didn't beause they don't perform as demonstrated if most of your ambient light is coming from the sides of the screen rather from the front. It was pointed out that the demos with the fluoros on were with the lights turned on at the front of the screen. Lights were turned off on the left and right side of the screen.To add they are not cheap.

[quote name=:)' timestamp='1329602082' post='1782299]

in my opinion, check out for your own eyes. while these ambient light rejecting screens do exist. like their benefits they also do have draw backs. Apart from being quite expensive vs conventional screens. check out for your self to decide :)

re wireless hdmi, dvdo provide the same tech as the epson as add on its a $399 item, not sure if available as yet in australia

http://store.spectra...ion-system.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ugg I get it now (another reason I like my light emmiting panel). So what is the cost of these 100" screens in Oz and is their a prefered retailer? Owen, I know you are a fan of the X30 but what would the combination of these sort of screen be like withthe Epson (for my current home situation the wireless HDMI is a big plus). The other option is I could add a HDMI Wireless Bridge to the X30..

The Black Diamond and Supernova screens work great with any projector and for a non dark viewing environment they are absolutely vital for a good image. Any white of gray screen is very poor in comparison.

The Epson will work better in a non dark environmnet than the JVC, but when its dark the JVC is king. The JVC's are the only digital front projectors that are up with the Kuro for contrast and black level is actually a lot lower than a Kuro in dark scenes.

I dont have an exact price for the screens but some where around $3k for a fixed, more for a roll up.

The Supernova is sold by Screen Technics, if you are interested in one we should get together with a group buy.

Edited by Owen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name=:)' timestamp='1329600420' post='1782296]

re the x30 if I bought one, I would be getting it calibrated. re the x3 before out of box needed calibration to my eyes.. And many do calibrate and also run a external scaler to have the isf capability to fully calibrate it. :) its also the reason some bought the x7 and looking at the x70 for full ISF calibration the x30 doesnt have,

Out of box the JVC is not setup to be accurate like most projectors, with the correct settings selected its close enough that I did not notice any colour issue and all my other display are calibrated. After calibration it did not look much different.

From the tests I have seen the Epson is no better and has the same need for calibration. The brighter modes on the Epson are way way off, just like other projectors.

The X30 does not have a CMS but the Standard preset is so close to the Rec709 standard that its a non issue, after gray scale and gamma are adjusted via the projectors controls I defy anyone to see any problems with colour.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name=:)' timestamp='1329602082' post='1782299]

while these ambient light rejecting screens do exist. like their benefits they also do have draw backs.

I am not aware of any draw backs to the Supernova screen, it has no hot spot, no texture and perfect colour accuracy.

The Black Diamond is prone to sparkles when viewed at relatively close distances, that's an issue for me so I am only interested in the Supernova or possibly the Draper ReAct II

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was ready to pull the trigger on one of these but didn't beause they don't perform as demonstrated if most of your ambient light is coming from the sides of the screen rather from the front. It was pointed out that the demos with the fluoros on were with the lights turned on at the front of the screen. Lights were turned off on the left and right side of the screen.To add they are not cheap.

Its no secret that these screens dont block light from the sides well, if they did horizontal viewing angles would be very limited. They do however block light going to or coming from vertical angles very well which is very important if you have a white ceiling and pale coloured floor.

The demonstration clearly show that its possible to light a room without destroying the projected image, something that is not possible with a white screen.

Edited by Owen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was ready to pull the trigger on one of these but didn't beause they don't perform as demonstrated if most of your ambient light is coming from the sides of the screen rather from the front. It was pointed out that the demos with the fluoros on were with the lights turned on at the front of the screen. Lights were turned off on the left and right side of the screen.To add they are not cheap.

The demo Owen posted was very impressive.. So your saying if the lighting is coming from the sides of the room or the back wall, you still have ambient light reflections and the screen doesn't have the desired effect like it did in the demo?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not aware of any draw backs to the Supernova screen, it has no hot spot, no texture and perfect colour accuracy.

The Black Diamond is prone to sparkles when viewed at relatively close distances, that's an issue for me so I am only interested in the Supernova or possibly the Draper ReAct II

I think crist answered aove and you yourself have answered question below,

Its no secret that these screens dont block light from the sides well, if they did horizontal viewing angles would be very limited. They do however block light going to or coming from vertical angles very well which is very important if you have a white ceiling and pale coloured floor.

The demonstration clearly show that its possible to light a room without destroying the projected image, something that is not possible with a white screen.

re black diamond as you say its draw backs are pretty well known, here is a quite from an owner

Hi Locksley, I was wondering if you could answer a few questions about your Supernova screen. It is very hard to find anybody who has this screen and can give a good review so any information would be great. I currently own a 92" Black Diamond 0.8 screen and as far as ambient light rejection it's great. Some of the limitations are Sparkles, a hot spot, and the off angle viewing is awful, you can move over just one seat and see a difference. My question to you is how does the supernova hold up in these areas. Thank you for any information.

supernova does address in some ways, but as suggested it really only covers for reflections off floor and ceiling ala where people havent painted their ceilings black or have dark carpets as do in bat caves. but still that doesnt make up for your typical white walls and leakage around windows with less than perfect 100% block out most people have in non dedicated rooms.

owen if you are serious about supernova screens check out the epic. it does weigh 300lbs apparently though ! :)

in anycase not to side track this thread suggest taking ambient light screen discussion to its relevant thread.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Out of box the JVC is not setup to be accurate like most projectors, with the correct settings selected its close enough that I did not notice any colour issue and all my other display are calibrated. After calibration it did not look much different.

From the tests I have seen the Epson is no better and has the same need for calibration. The brighter modes on the Epson are way way off, just like other projectors.

The X30 does not have a CMS but the Standard preset is so close to the Rec709 standard that its a non issue, after gray scale and gamma are adjusted via the projectors controls I defy anyone to see any problems with colour.

I think we will agree to dissagree on out of box performance of these owen, otherwise I know like some other threads gone by you still be arguing about it 22 pages later ! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name=:)' timestamp='1329600420' post='1782296]

not correct on the warranty. I actually owned the previous flagship epson 5500 and current 9000. the warranty you are getting muddled in your head. Its something I not only confirmed with epson but also retailer and service centre not only for the previous model but also the current. and the fine print is actually quite clear, but I checked anyway.

http://www.epson.com...jector_3Y3Y.asp

the projector without lamp is warranted for 3 years. the lamp supplied with the projector is warranted for 3 years. if you buy a lamp separate to the projector it is warranted to 12 months or 750 hours which ever comes first.

re the x30 if I bought one, I would be getting it calibrated. re the x3 before out of box needed calibration to my eyes.. And many do calibrate and also run a external scaler to have the isf capability to fully calibrate it. :) its also the reason some bought the x7 and looking at the x70 for full ISF calibration the x30 doesnt have,

OK, I was re-read the warranty term I was wrong. But according to all the review I have seen on x30 and I have x3 the default setting is very accurate. I have calibrate x3 with/without external scaler ( I have 3D mini), X3 out of box can be calibrated with a few clicks in the usual greyscale control settings ( like rgb gain/bias) to bring the colour temperature in line with 6500K, gamma is easily adjusted to 2.2 and colour even without the cms is pretty good. The reason some bought x7 was because of its implementation of cms and better contrast. A lot of potential x7 buyers also went with Lumagen mini 3D and x3 instead of x7 because Lumagen's implementation of cms is superior than x7 and not as buggy as x7. Many feel the overall PQ of x3 and lumagen is superior than x7 and also the combo is cheaper than x7. X30 and x70 is different because of e-shift feature on x70.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Al , yes a new projector appeals to me more and from all accounts the 9000 in eco etc might suit the bill .....l'm coming from a Sony HS60 ( which has been bulletproof, just dimmish )

Used JVC's are hard to come by when your after one lol , but i'm not in a great rush ( so long as it's next week ! :) )

Seriously , the old Sony will suffice until need be, just keen to upgrade soon to 1080p ...the other good thing with the 9000 is the wireless HDMI , as my wall that the original HDMI runs up is located under a second story , so impossible to access for a straight pull up and l'd hate to try and pull though a new cable and lose it halfway ( l know the holes are'nt very big as l ran it 6 years ago )

The 9000 looking pretty good atm ( unless a nice higher end JVC comes about at the right price :) )

Cheers Ken

ken I missed this post of yours, from previous sony owners would be worth comparing notes with both cwt and crist who moved from sony to the epson. the sonys have always had a respect for. and would be worth investigating what else in store from sony thats comparable. perhaps something to look out for anyways just as another option to throw in the mix :) re higher end jvc's there is the x70 that sits above the x30.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote name=:)' timestamp='1329607582' post='1782332]

I think we will agree to dissagree on out of box performance of these owen, otherwise I know like some other threads gone by you still be arguing about it 22 pages later ! :D

Al, have you actually measured or calibrate a x3 or x30 ? If you haven't you really don't have much to say regarding the out of box performance of x3. Tom Hoffman who developed Chromapure software actually said in his post in AVS it took him 20 minutes to fully calibrate a x3 and he said the default cinema setting in x3 was pretty much spot on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Al, have you actually measured or calibrate a x3 or x30 ? If you haven't you really don't have much to say regarding the out of box performance of x3. Tom Hoffman who developed Chromapure software actually said in his post in AVS it took him 20 minutes to fully calibrate a x3 and he said the default cinema setting in x3 was pretty much spot on.

Have seen the out of box performance of the jvc x3. Have seen with my own eyes the x3 calibrated and uncalibrated. That's all I need to see. I have also seen an x30 calibrated. The jvc guy at the Melbourne show demoing the jvc x30 recommended to factor in a calibration.

And i would suggest as both you and Owen have done with your jvc x3's for any one considering to factor in a calibration. If they get it and decide not something to bother with that's their bonus.

Again as per Owen am happy to agree to disagree with you on this matter no wish to argue this to death.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just demoed the X30 and X90 in dedicated HT showrooms (using http://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Leonard-Cohen-Songs-from-the-Road-Blu-ray/13943/ which I thought was an odd choice and to which I am also unfamilliar). The X30 was projecting onto a JP Morgan 100" fixed screen and it gave the best overall comparison to what I could expect at home. My impressions where:

1) colour and bright scenes were pleasing and looked pretty good

2) blacks were crushed, and suffered from "back crawl" (Given Owen's comments I was surprised at this but to be fair I've never seen the disk before either so it could be an issue with the source)

3) some ambient light was OK in the room (had white walls but dark ceiling) but oddly they had some halogens mounted over the screen that washed out the picture.

4) the X90 "may" have been better with blacks but it was in a different room with an older "grey hawk" screen so it was hard to be objective

Summary: I think I need to "relax" my expectations on the picture quality and on the versatility for these units. So....I figure at night, put up the screen, power up the PJ, open a good bottle of red and just kick back and enjoy some mindless block busters.....as if I start comparing it with the daytime performance of the Kuro I'm just going to be disappointed, regardless of what I'm going to be able to do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I saw the X3 demoed last year the picture looked impressive. I think that that one was calibrated by the hifi store. The display room although not a complete batcave was pretty close to one ie black walls dark ceiling but the entrance was not a solid wall but a dark curtain which allowed some light to sneak in where it was drawn together.

I savoured the moment thinking if I was going to get a new PJ this would be my reference point however the lumen output of the JVC would be an issue in the less than ideal setting of my family room. The Epson light cannon solved it all for me. I get good blacks and the image just pops.

Edited by Crist

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Summary: I think I need to "relax" my expectations on the picture quality and on the versatility for these units. So....I figure at night, put up the screen, power up the PJ, open a good bottle of red and just kick back and enjoy some mindless block busters.....as if I start comparing it with the daytime performance of the Kuro I'm just going to be disappointed, regardless of what I'm going to be able to do.

After a few glasses of red you couldn't care less anyway :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jmone, great to see have started checking out for yourself. best thing can do to get feel for things to help your decision.

crist similar story here, the x3 have seen do a great job calibrated and in a dedicated room setting. for me either the jvc or the previous epson was the toss up. but yeah in my non dedicated room setting was very happy with my choice in the epson and even happier with the 9000 now. but yeah not to say the jvc not an excellent choice in the right conditions. people will choose whats best for their needs. and plenty of people very happy with either.

Personally I think we're extremely lucky to be able to buy these kind of pjs for the kind of money they go for.

ps another not to be forgotted in this mix is the pana 7000. though shares much with the epson. has some points of differentiation that will make it the right choice for some as well :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Owen, Al? & Crist - May I ask what screens you gents are currently using and any comments?

Edited by jmone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.