Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What Exactly Is A Sd Top Box?
DTV Forum Australia - Australia's Leading Digital TV and AV Forum > Digital TV Receivers & Related Products > SD Set Top Box Receivers
TruthSeeker
I am confused, sorry.

But why would a person buy a SD top box, if all it shows is what I can currently see on TV right now on my Audiosonic 51" TV?

What will buying a SDB do for me?

And if I should get one, what brands should I avoid, and what brands should I consider?

And is it possible to connect a Hard Drive to the box to record TV shows?

Thanks
50MXE20
Widescreen. Digital vs analogue.

Add a HDD which is a SD STB and called a SD PVR and get a lot of programming flexibility.
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (Lyle @ Mar 11 2009, 11:26 AM) *
Widescreen. Digital vs analogue.

Add a HDD which is a SD STB and called a SD PVR and get a lot of programming flexibility.


So you mean a SDB will turn a wide screen reception to 4:3, making everything looks squashed?

And I do experience ghosting and static at the moment. Will buying a SDB give me better picture without ghosting etc?

And can you please elaborate on your comments about adding a HDD? What SDB do I need to do that?
50MXE20
Pinned: Pete's Pvr Post - Diving Into Digital Tv
pgdownload
Lyle = Fast & Succinct (Avatar does seem to suit) smile.gif

Over the next 1-3 years analogue broadcasting will cease. So eventually you will have no choice but to get a digital tuner of some sort (either a STB, built into a TV or in a recording device (ie a digital VCR).

If you have really good analogue reception on all channels then digital has less to often. Usually though most people have at least one dogey reception station and one or two others with some form of interference. If you can get digital reception then usually it will be 100% crisp clear pictures on ALL channels.

These days you'd generally recommend a HD STB for people looking to buy. The price is maybe $50 more than a comparable SD one and you get HD and SD channels. There will be 15 channels in total, some SD ones broadcasting simply a SD version of the HD channel (for those that only have SD boxes).

As mentioned widescreen is a plus for digital TV (same as all DVDs are encoded) but obviously you'd need to get a new TV to take advantage of it.

As you surmise though, better than a STB is a STB with a harddrive built in. These are called PVRs and range from $250 to $1000. They can offer a real boost to your viewing pleasure. Things like being able to record two things at once, skip ads, pause live Tv while you answer the door, etc.

There are a couple of stickies on PVRS and digital TV in general - This one is probably the least technical.

FWIW These days any STB will basically work fine. Just go into a Good Guys or the like and ask the sales guy what he recommends (keeping in mind that anything more than $100 for SD or $150 for HD is probably overkill and you'll get no additional benefit.

To answer your main query though, a STB takes a digital signal from the aerial and translates it back into an analogue one so your existing TV can understand it.

Regards

Peter Gillespie
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 11:39 AM) *
Lyle = Fast & Succinct (Avatar does seem to suit) smile.gif

Over the next 1-3 years analogue broadcasting will cease. So eventually you will have no choice but to get a digital tuner of some sort (either a STB, built into a TV or in a recording device (ie a digital VCR).

If you have really good analogue reception on all channels then digital has less to often. Usually though most people have at least one dogey reception station and one or two others with some form of interference. If you can get digital reception then usually it will be 100% crisp clear pictures on ALL channels.

These days you'd generally recommend a HD STB for people looking to buy. The price is maybe $50 more than a comparable SD one and you get HD and SD channels. There will be 15 channels in total, some SD ones broadcasting simply a SD version of the HD channel (for those that only have SD boxes).

As mentioned widescreen is a plus for digital TV (same as all DVDs are encoded) but obviously you'd need to get a new TV to take advantage of it.

As you surmise though, better than a STB is a STB with a harddrive built in. These are called PVRs and range from $250 to $1000. They can offer a real boost to your viewing pleasure. Things like being able to record two things at once, skip ads, pause live Tv while you answer the door, etc.

There are a couple of stickies on PVRS and digital TV in general - This one is probably the least technical.

FWIW These days any STB will basically work fine. Just go into a Good Guys or the like and ask the sales guy what he recommends (keeping in mind that anything more than $100 for SD or $150 for HD is probably overkill and you'll get no additional benefit.

To answer your main query though, a STB takes a digital signal from the aerial and translates it back into an analogue one so your existing TV can understand it.

Regards

Peter Gillespie



Peter, what does this mean when you said "If you have really good analogue reception on all channels then digital has less to often." ? That sentence made no sense at all to me. Were you trying to say that the ghosting and static I get now on TV will still be there even if I bought a SD top box?

And how will the digital widescreen signal look on my 4:3 51" TV? Does it look squashed up and funny looking?

And what does PVR stand for anyway?

Thanks Peter :-)
pgdownload
This is going to be one of those real time conversational threads it appears smile.gif

Yes digital TV is basically free of all the reception issues of analogue on all channels (its generally is either 100% good or you get zero picture - not a lot in between)

Analogue TV is broadcast in 4:3 (your current TV ratio). Digital TV is broadcast in 16:9 (widescreen). A STB will have a button to toggle the aspect ratio, so if you hook it up to your current TV then the image will not look distorted you'll just lose the extra bits of the left and right of your TV (which would be shown if your TV was w i d e r)

Regards

Peter Gillespie
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 11:43 AM) *
This is going to be one of those real time conversational threads it appears smile.gif

Yes digital TV is basically free of all the reception issues of analogue on all channels (its generally is either 100% good or you get zero picture - not a lot in between)

Analogue TV is broadcast in 4:3 (your current TV ratio). Digital TV is broadcast in 16:9 (widescreen). A STB will have a button to toggle the aspect ratio, so if you hook it up to your current TV then the image will not look distorted you'll just lose the extra bits of the left and right of your TV (which would be shown if your TV was w i d e r)

Regards

Peter Gillespie


So buying even a SDB for $35 from Kmart, will give me access to ABC, 7,9,10,SBS without the static and ghosting I see now?

BTW, does SD mean Standard Definition or Standard Digital?

pgdownload
QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Mar 11 2009, 11:43 AM) *
Peter, what does this mean when you said "If you have really good analogue reception on all channels then digital has less to often." ?
Umm yes, well that's because you're obviously not very bright wink.gif If I can figure it out I'll try rephrase it...

It started well but I must have got distracted so, ah no wait, its just a single letter (replace the last 'n' with an 'r')

FWIW, if you quote lengthy pieces (like mine) its usually a good idea to delete it all in your follow up otherwise threads get very long very quickly.

QUOTE
Were you trying to say that the ghosting and static I get now on TV will still be there even if I bought a SD top box?
No simply that if you have no ghosting and static now then digital will look much the same. But as you do have ghosting and static then digital would likely give you a much nicer picture quality.
QUOTE
And how will the digital widescreen signal look on my 4:3 51" TV? Does it look squashed up and funny looking?
As mentioned no, there is a button on the remote to toggle various modes and one will look normal.
QUOTE
And what does PVR stand for anyway?
Its debatable, but probably "Personal Digital Recorder"
There are a couple of good general FAQs on digital TV here

Regards

Peter Gillespie
pgdownload
QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Mar 11 2009, 11:46 AM) *
So buying even a SDB for $35 from Kmart, will give me access to ABC, 7,9,10,SBS without the static and ghosting I see now?
Yes. Plus you get the pretty nifty ABC2 with some good content and shortly the Ten 24/7 SD sport channel starting in a month or so
QUOTE
BTW, does SD mean Standard Definition or Standard Digital?
Both terms mean the same thing really, the first is more correct though. I'd suggest you start doing some reading on the links provided (they do answer these things smile.gif) and after that bamboozles you come back and see if we can't fill in any gaps.

Regards

Peter Gillespie
jakes
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 11:58 AM) *
Umm yes, well that's because you're obviously not very bright wink.gif If I can figure it out I'll try rephrase it...

It started well but I must have got distracted so, ah no wait, its just a single letter (replace the last 'n' with an 'r')

Actually, two letters - the t also needs to be replaced with an 'f' wink.gif
mtv
QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Mar 11 2009, 11:46 AM) *
So buying even a SDB for $35 from Kmart, will give me access to ABC, 7,9,10,SBS without the static and ghosting I see now?

BTW, does SD mean Standard Definition or Standard Digital?


QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Jan 14 2009, 08:00 AM) *
But I only have a 32" HD 720p LCD TV.


QUOTE (aztec @ Jan 12 2009, 03:10 PM) *
You might be better off visiting the Whirpool forum.


QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Jan 12 2009, 03:44 PM) *
I can't, I am banned from there :-)


The last post says it all.

Just another troll
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 12:00 PM) *
Yes. Plus you get the pretty nifty ABC2 with some good content and shortly the Ten 24/7 SD sport channel starting in a month or so Both terms mean the same thing really, the first is more correct though. I'd suggest you start doing some reading on the links provided (they do answer these things smile.gif) and after that bamboozles you come back and see if we can't fill in any gaps.

Regards

Peter Gillespie


So Ten 24/7 will also be broadcast in SD? I thought it was only going to be in HD?

So if I buy a SDB and not a HDB, all I will miss out on is some late night programs on HD Ten? Is that right?


TruthSeeker
QUOTE (mtv @ Mar 11 2009, 12:06 PM) *
The last post says it all.

Just another troll


Not a troll, just a man who asks questions so I can learn.

And sadly, because I ask questions, some people hate me and even ask for me to banned.

Thanks.
pgdownload
QUOTE (jakes @ Mar 11 2009, 12:03 PM) *
Actually, two letters - the t also needs to be replaced with an 'f' wink.gif
Sometimes I prefer to say f off smile.gif

Regards

Peter Gillespie
pgdownload
and I was just about to start doing a background check MTV. T'was a good thread too. Thanks for taking an interest though. Personally I'm not too worried if people are banned elsewhere but comments such as "I only have a 32" HD 720p LCD TV" are disappointing. Never quite sure what the point of these threads are but I guess its always good to learn a little humility. smile.gif

Regards

Peter Gillespie
50MXE20
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 10:20 AM) *
and I was just about to start doing a background check MTV. T'was a good thread too. Thanks for taking an interest though. Personally I'm not too worried if people are banned elsewhere but comments such as "I only have a 32" HD 720p LCD TV" are disappointing. Never quite sure what the point of these threads are but I guess its always good to learn a little humility. smile.gif
biggrin.gif laugh.gif

Seeing the same questions appearing in 3 or 4 threads made me start to get suspicious.

Now new acronyms are being created that mean nothing to any of us! Sheesh.
Eggles
Without wading through all the ins and outs of the various replies... may I offer this to the OP? I purchased a set top box (just an SD one) some years back, and the difference it made to the quality of my picture was astounding. My reception was really poor, as I live in a 'shadow' in inner east suburban Melbourne, and put up with poor picture quality for years. But the reception I get via the STB is great - a few tiny pauses in the picture occasionally which are nothing compared to the superior picture I now get. Well worth the money I spent.
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (Eggles @ Mar 11 2009, 05:24 PM) *
Without wading through all the ins and outs of the various replies... may I offer this to the OP? I purchased a set top box (just an SD one) some years back, and the difference it made to the quality of my picture was astounding. My reception was really poor, as I live in a 'shadow' in inner east suburban Melbourne, and put up with poor picture quality for years. But the reception I get via the STB is great - a few tiny pauses in the picture occasionally which are nothing compared to the superior picture I now get. Well worth the money I spent.


Thank you Eggles for your comments. Tomorrow I am going to buy a top box, look forward to it. As you, I been putting up with ghosted, static, white bars picture for years.
johndee
QUOTE (Eggles @ Mar 11 2009, 05:24 PM) *
Without wading through all the ins and outs of the various replies... may I offer this to the OP? I purchased a set top box (just an SD one) some years back, and the difference it made to the quality of my picture was astounding. My reception was really poor, as I live in a 'shadow' in inner east suburban Melbourne, and put up with poor picture quality for years. But the reception I get via the STB is great - a few tiny pauses in the picture occasionally which are nothing compared to the superior picture I now get. Well worth the money I spent.

I will second that.
I started out with a Sd set top box on a normal CRT TV, and was surprised at the increase in picture quality.
The STB is in the bedroom now, I have replaced it with a PVR (Or 2)
I would reccomend looking at a PVR (I picked up a 2nd hand Digicrystal from Cash Converters very cheap).
The way I use it has revolutionised the way I wach TV.
JB
Bosch
The only downside of digital TV is that you'll end up watching more TV than ever before!
diesel
Hence the need for a PVR cool.gif
PennyPacker
TruthSeeker, first up, there's nothing wrong with asking questions so settle down and I'll explain my situation. I live in a fringe reception area where I need a masthead amplifier but even that did not give a good signal - at times the picture was crap especially CH9. I have a widescreen (16:9 aspect ratio) CRT (cathode ray tube, not LCD or plasma) TV and I hooked up an SD (standard definition) STB (set top box) and I now get a great crisp interference-free picture. The improvement in quality is remarkable.

I also have 2 other CRT TVs, both are 4:3 aspect ratios and have SD STBs attached. They give beaut pictures, not squashed or distorted in any way but obviously as mentioned in a previous post the picture probably loses a bit on the sides but I really hadn't noticed.

Also TruthSeeker. with digital reception you can access a lot more stuff for instance digital radio and in addition to your normal ABC (now called ABC1) you can tune into ABC2. You also get EPG (electronic program guide) at your finger tips so you don't have to get off your bum and reach for the TV Week. Although having said that, both the EPG and the paper one are probably not worth much these days as the TV stations are constantly changing their minds about what programs to transmit.

Hope this helps.

PP.
diesel
And don't forget you get subtitles as well
Rogal Dorn
Hi guys - new member here and coming to the whole DTV issue from a point of profound ignorance. I'm thinking of buying my first box soon, having previously had Foxtel (standard, not HD) but now getting that disconnected.

I have a couple of questions that I would be very grateful for some basic steers on.

1) I have a CRT tv, that is widescreen, and has a 100mhz refresh - my understanding from reading up briefly (and understanding little jargon) is that there is no point for me in buying a true HD set top box, as opposed to a SD set top box - as my tv won't be able to display anything more than SD anyhow. Is this accurate? Or is there some reason why I should pay the extra for an HD box now? (unfortunately I don't have the money to buy a new HD-capable tv)

2) I'm wanting this unit to be something I can plug in and then largely forget about, so simplicity and reliability are probably the two key values for me. What are the top boxes in the approx $100 and approx $150 price ranges for these values.

3) A PVR sounds cool, is there a SD box that is a self contained PVR that meets that simplicity/reliability test, and how much might that roughly cost.

Sorry, I know from a few forums where I'm not a noob who knows nothing about the subject matter that these spoon-feeding questions are annoying sometimes, especially if I'm the hundredth person to ask this (I did have a look first and didn't notice any thread set up for this sort of thing, or recent answers to similar questions). Grateful for any guidance here, as I'd rather not just take the salesman's word for things.
50MXE20
QUOTE (Rogal Dorn @ Mar 12 2009, 10:45 PM) *
I have a couple of questions that I would be very grateful for some basic steers on.

Pinned: Digital Recorders Help: Stbs, Pvrs, Dvdrs, Hdd, Sd, Hd ....

Pinned: Pete's Pvr Post - Diving Into Digital Tv
alanh
All,
If you buy an SD STB when Freeview starts you will get a 10 different programs to pick from if you buy an HD STB will get 15 programs to pick from. Comisserations to those in regional WA & NT you will only 4 and 6 respectively until commercial DTV starts.Regional SA 6 and 8 respectively.

All STBs can provide signals to the old TVs.

AlanH
Rogal Dorn
QUOTE (Lyle @ Mar 13 2009, 01:24 AM) *


Thanks, obviously just didn't look in the right place. They're very helpful summaries.
diesel
QUOTE (Rogal Dorn @ Mar 13 2009, 12:45 AM) *
Hi guys - new member here...

1) is that there is no point for me in buying a true HD set top box, as opposed to a SD set top box -
All boxes convert digital to analogue so buying an SD or HD box is no different except HD box adds the HD channels as well. They will both work fine with your TV, and you can continue to use it on your old TV when you get a new one

2) I'm wanting this unit to be something I can plug in and then largely forget about, so simplicity and reliability are probably the two key values for me. What are the top boxes in the approx $100 and approx $150 price ranges for these values. Topfield 7010 is well regarded

3) A PVR sounds cool, is there a SD box that is a self contained PVR that meets that simplicity/reliability test, and how much might that roughly cost. Again, Topfield sell some good SD PVRs like the TF5000

TruthSeeker
QUOTE (PennyPacker @ Mar 12 2009, 03:54 PM) *
...

Hope this helps.

PP.


Yes Penny, that helped a lot.

I bought a HD STB from Coles yesterday for $49.

Wow, what an amazing picture I now get on all channels, even the HD ones. I can now even watch ABC and SBS as before they were too static and ghosted to watch.

TruthSeeker
QUOTE (Rogal Dorn @ Mar 13 2009, 12:45 AM) *
Hi guys - new member here and coming to the whole DTV issue from a point of profound ignorance. I'm thinking of buying my first box soon, having previously had Foxtel (standard, not HD) but now getting that disconnected.

I have a couple of questions that I would be very grateful for some basic steers on.

1) I have a CRT tv, that is widescreen, and has a 100mhz refresh - my understanding from reading up briefly (and understanding little jargon) is that there is no point for me in buying a true HD set top box, as opposed to a SD set top box - as my tv won't be able to display anything more than SD anyhow. Is this accurate? Or is there some reason why I should pay the extra for an HD box now? (unfortunately I don't have the money to buy a new HD-capable tv)

2) I'm wanting this unit to be something I can plug in and then largely forget about, so simplicity and reliability are probably the two key values for me. What are the top boxes in the approx $100 and approx $150 price ranges for these values.

3) A PVR sounds cool, is there a SD box that is a self contained PVR that meets that simplicity/reliability test, and how much might that roughly cost.

Sorry, I know from a few forums where I'm not a noob who knows nothing about the subject matter that these spoon-feeding questions are annoying sometimes, especially if I'm the hundredth person to ask this (I did have a look first and didn't notice any thread set up for this sort of thing, or recent answers to similar questions). Grateful for any guidance here, as I'd rather not just take the salesman's word for things.


1. You will only see 576i I think, which still looks awesome on my 51cm CRT TV. Looks like watching a DVD.

2. I bought a HD STB from Coles for $49, so I can watch the extra channels that are available now and will come in the future. If you buy just a SD STB, you will not be able to watch the extra channels.


diesel
QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Mar 13 2009, 08:59 AM) *
If you buy just a SD STB, you will not be able to watch the extra channels.

Not quite right.

The HD channels have been around for more than 12 months. It's another batch of SD channels that we will get to take the total to 15, but if you buy a SD STB, you won't get the HD channels.
50MXE20
QUOTE (diesel @ Mar 13 2009, 04:50 PM) *
Not quite right.

The HD channels have been around for more than 12 months. It's another batch of SD channels that we will get to take the total to 15, but if you buy a SD STB, you won't get the HD channels.
Nor the 5.1 sound.
Timmy Downawell
QUOTE (mtv @ Mar 11 2009, 12:06 PM) *
The last post says it all.

Just another troll


But you left out

QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Feb 25 2009, 11:38 AM) *
Where can I get a really cheap HD top box for my 51cm analogue Audiosonic TV?

tonymy01
His posts are very troll like, but reading a bit further into them, he really didn't have a clue, and wasn't getting a clue with the help over at whirlpool. It appears he is on the right track now, enjoying his Coles HD STB.
I think I found in one of his whirlpool (or was it here) posts that he only had that LCD temporarily, which explains that.
Next thing I think he doesn't understand is that the " symbol means inches, because he sometimes says 51" analogue and sometimes says 51cm analogue for presumably the same TV. But all is well that ends well.
TruthSeeker
QUOTE (tonymy01 @ Mar 13 2009, 11:26 PM) *
His posts are very troll like, but reading a bit further into them, he really didn't have a clue, and wasn't getting a clue with the help over at whirlpool. It appears he is on the right track now, enjoying his Coles HD STB.
I think I found in one of his whirlpool (or was it here) posts that he only had that LCD temporarily, which explains that.
Next thing I think he doesn't understand is that the " symbol means inches, because he sometimes says 51" analogue and sometimes says 51cm analogue for presumably the same TV. But all is well that ends well.



Yep, all is good now :-) Love it.
mtv
SPAMMER reported
michael_c
Of course, if your current signal has issues like ghosting and noise... these same issues are affecting the signal your digital set-top box is receiving (if the digital signal is coming from the same tower as the analog signal.)
You won't see the ghosting and noise but the receiver section in the STB has to work harder to pull the signal out of the crud. Just because ghosting (multipath reception) doesn't appear on your screen, doesn't mean it won't cause dropouts and digital artifacts.
Don't use a digital STB as a cure-all for poor TV reception...



QUOTE (TruthSeeker @ Mar 11 2009, 05:00 PM) *
Thank you Eggles for your comments. Tomorrow I am going to buy a top box, look forward to it. As you, I been putting up with ghosted, static, white bars picture for years.

dax
QUOTE (michael_c @ Mar 24 2009, 07:30 AM) *
Of course, if your current signal has issues like ghosting and noise... these same issues are affecting the signal your digital set-top box is receiving (if the digital signal is coming from the same tower as the analog signal.)
You won't see the ghosting and noise but the receiver section in the STB has to work harder to pull the signal out of the crud. Just because ghosting (multipath reception) doesn't appear on your screen, doesn't mean it won't cause dropouts and digital artifacts.
Don't use a digital STB as a cure-all for poor TV reception...


But the digital transmission is designed to more resilient against these common problems.
Sure it cant magically solve terrible reception - but it will be good against problems like multipath that cause minor ghosting in analog.

Analog6
QUOTE (pgdownload @ Mar 11 2009, 10:39 AM) *
To answer your main query though, a STB takes a digital signal from the aerial and translates it back into an analogue one so your existing TV can understand it.

Regards

Peter Gillespie

Thank you, Peter - that's the succinct answer I've been looking for since they started all this stuff.

Maybe you can help me (I'm putting this in here as I cannot make a new thread for some reason).

I have AWA STB 237 (bought 18 months or so ago); Philips DVDR 3455H; Tevion T2195B 51cm Noraml Flat CRT TV.

Can they all be connected in any way? If I use the STB I cannot record. The TV has 2 inputs for the red/yellow/white and a YUV (green/red/blue). I had the antenna going into the DVDR and that connected to the Tv by the the YUV cable. This worked well but some channels were fuzzy. CAn the STB be integrated into this or does the antenna have top go into it (which is how it appears to me). Any assistance gratefully reecieved.

ATM I have the STB connected. The HD channels show 50% or better reception but there is no pic or sound. Why is this so?

Edited: I did it! I got them all connected. I had to go aerial cable (the black one) to STB, then to DVDR, then to TV.

And I have R/Y/W stb to DVDR then to TV plus a set of compnenet cables DVDR to TV. I found a button on the DVDR remote that said 'Source' and that was the key. I cannot beleive I am finally connected. Just have to test out recorduing.
diesel
QUOTE (Analog6 @ Apr 13 2009, 12:32 PM) *
ATM I have the STB connected. The HD channels show 50% or better reception but there is no pic or sound. Why is this so?

Edited: I did it! I got them all connected. I had to go aerial cable (the black one) to STB, then to DVDR, then to TV.

The HD channels may not appear if the STB is only designed for Standard Definition (SD)
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.